The winners of the Knight News Challenge on Networks have been announced on Monday at the 2012 MIT-Knight Civic Media Conference. The revamped competition is the first one of three, has more focus, and is tied to specific themes that, according to the organization, “better mirror the pace of innovation.”
During this round, the organization has awarded more than $1.37 million to media innovation startups, that range, according to the Knight Foundation, “from an aggregator of mobile video streams of breaking news to a platform that coordinates community disaster recovery.”
As Joshua Benton writes at Nieman Journalism Lab, the makeover of the competition — breaking it in three shorter rounds with specific themes in particular — is a definite improvement from the previous years. He notes:
[M]y unscientific observation was that the general quality of applications was up; the 52 entries that made it to the first cut seemed particularly strong and drew on what felt like a broader base of applicants than previous rounds had.
Jon Mitchell has an interesting observation on the winners, expressing surprise that these ventures haven’t come into existence sooner. He writes on ReadWriteWeb:
This year’s crop proposes fairly obvious ideas. It’s surprising that some of these haven’t been built already. Why does the Knight Foundation have to fund something as basic as a browsable map for live videos? There’s one clear answer: News organizations — for whatever reason — haven’t built them themselves.
You be the judge. The six winners are:
Leveraging streaming networks like Ustream and TweetCaster, Peepol.TV will aggregate live mobile video streams of breaking news events into an easily searchable world map, connecting users directly to global events as they unfold.
After a tornado destroyed their Massachusetts home, two sisters created an online organizing platform that helps disaster-stricken communities quickly launch recovery efforts. In the immediate aftermath of a disaster, Recovers.org enables communities to launch a website that ensures that heightened news attention translates into donations, volunteers and more.
Enabling newsrooms to monitor what is resonating with readers and make smarter editorial decisions about which stories get covered and promoted, Signalnoi.se is a dashboard that tracks stories through social networks and across competitor sites.
An iPad app that makes it easier to find and watch high-quality news videos, Watchup speeds the search for relevant content by offering a curated playlist that aggregates news reports into a simple interface.
Behavio is an open-source platform that turns phones into smart sensors of people’s real world behavior, from how they use their phones to how they communicate with others. Funding will be used to help programmers build apps with smarter sensors, create tools for journalists that uncover trends in community data and launch a mobile application that allows individuals to explore data about their lives.
- Tor Project
With journalists and their sources increasingly threatened by governments, criminal organizations and others who monitor their mobile and online communication, the Tor Project will use its vast network of volunteers to create a tool kit that will enable journalists to communicate more safely with sources by using the organization’s secure Web browser, an anonymous upload utility and more.
Interestingly, Signalnoi.se aims to do what could be considered another nail in the coffin of any print newspaper that had experienced staff cutbacks and had more of less ended up going digital, as was the case most recently with The Times-Picayune in New Orleans. Co-founded by Mohamed Nanabhay, former head of new media at Al Jazeera, and Haroon Meer, the startup provides editorial analytics to see what topics and headlines resonate with readers the most, identifying trends and surges of interest.
The company summary on the Knight Foundation website says Signalnoi.se intends “to extract the signal from the noise and close the loop between what audiences are interested in and what editors focus resources on”:
With newsrooms stretched for resources, editors have to increasingly make difficult decisions about which stories get covered and promoted. Signalnoi.se aims to help, by tracking social engagement with the news — scanning social network activity to provide real-time information on what’s resonating with readers. Editors are able to track their own — and competitors’ — stories.
Another noteworthy winning entry, Tor Project, focuses on privacy, security, and online anonymity. It promises to provide a “toolkit for journalists” that will help protect them from those who might “track their online and mobile communication to see who is talking to the press.” The Knight Foundation website says in a summary:
The kit will include The Tor Project’s secure Web browser and anonymous upload utility, along with new tools and training videos.
Other potential users include activists, the law enforcement and the military, businesses in search of confidentiality and those that need to research competition or conduct an internal investigation; and anyone who wants to shield himself or herself from traffic analysis or wants some family privacy online.
Two of the winners, the Knight Foundation notes, Signalnoi.se and Watchup, are receiving funding through the Knight Enterprise Fund, an early-stage venture fund that invests in for-profit ventures. The second round of the 2012 Knight News Challenge, on data, is accepting applications through June 21. The topic of the third will be announced later this year, the organization says.
Image by the Knight Foundation, used under Fair Use: Reporting.